Yeah, you always wonder if someone is so stupid or so smart.

Anyway, I've said already a couple of times, that the edits NEEDS to be made for much broader audience. Of course, I don't want here to complain about them, because most of them are fine and really improving the movie. They do the job well, but I'm afraid mostly only for us. There are many things which bothers us (Ewoks or fake looking enviroment in prequels), but for the general audience they are ok. Certainly there are a few things, which bothers even the general audience - Jar Jar (although, it depends, mostly on your age) or love story in AOTC.

The only one edit I would shown to non SW fans is SW:Revisited. But still, for the first time, I would go with the official DVD version (or BD in the near future). For ESB maybe I would use the theatrical reconstruction from the greatest editor of all time, ADY :).

As for the sister from Darth Bizzaro - well, she is certainly no SW fan, but she is not alpha and omega. I mean, showing someone SW for the first time (I know how it is, because I made that with someone from my family year ago) and seeing what reaction and comments we get, depends on with which kind of person we are watching the movie. For example, when you are watching the movies with 10 years old boy, he will certainly love Jar Jar, fall asleep during politics talks or love story. But he will love the actions sequences or Ewoks. Maybe he will hate young Anakin, I hated him when I was a boy in 99/00/01. On the other site, when you are watching it with man who is 27 years old, he will for 99% hate Jar Jar and all the "comical" scenes, but he will maybe be interested in politics (Palpatine rise to power), or Vaders sacrifice for his son or Lukes adventures. His will understand his frustration and willingness to get off from this rock.