logo Sign In

Post #509102

Author
DuracellEnergizer
Parent topic
Star Wars: Episode I - The Beginning (AKA DuracellEnergizer's Take On TPM)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/509102/action/topic#509102
Date created
23-Jun-2011, 11:13 PM

xhonzi said:


I have to echo VideInfra.  I personally doubt that anyone starting with  George's PT base can deliver a satisfying PT to me.  That's why I don't watch fanedits of PT movies (though I've tried a couple) and immediately dismiss something that includes Naboo or Gungans, etc.

Heaven knows, it' hard enough to dump all of the influences from the gPT even when you're trying.  Let alone when you're selectively trying to include stuff.


Like I said, I can see where you're coming from - I myself have a hard time reading anything Star Wars that heavily features PT-style Sith & Jedi. But I'm primarily writing this script for myself, though, more than for anyone else. Sure, I like sharing it with others and don't mind receiving criticism, but it's going to reflect my specific tastes and I'm not very interested in tailoring it to suit anybody else's.

I appreciate the feedback, though. It's nice to know where everyone's coming from.