VideInfra78 said:
ChainsawAsh said:
The basic thrust of ROTJ is good - rebels gain intel on a way to deal a death blow to the Empire, but it's really a trap to draw the rebellion out in the open and destroy them for good.
Here's the specific things I would have changed:
- We don't see the Emperor until the final act, when Luke does
- NO FRIGGIN' DEATH STARS!
- The final battle involves an epic space battle above Coruscant, intercut with an epic ground battle where rebels of all alien species (diversity is important here) are fighting to gain control of the capital
- The Emperor isn't actually on Coruscant, he's on another planet
- Luke is forcibly captured by Vader rather than giving himself in
- Vader is a badass who wipes out huge quantities of troops on his own
- When Vader captures Luke, it's very clear what his plan is - he wants Luke to join him and overthrow the Emperor so they can rule together
- Leia is NOT Luke's sister
- Han dies, and Luke & Leia are together at the end (possibly at Han's funeral)There are other changes, but this is the overall gist. I'd really like to write a completely alternate ROTJ, honestly.
I second each point of all of this.
me too. ROTJ really deserved a story that would have taken it to new heights instead of the same old same old. The next sequel could include the other Jedi hopeful Yoda mentioned in ESB (it wasn't Leia. not if Obi-Wan believed Luke was their only hope. durrr).