Harmy said:

Another thing is R2's blue in the shots where we see him behind Luke in the x-wing. It is much better than in the SE but still doesn't seem quite right (and I totally understand why, I encountered the same problems when making the panels black for my edit). Would it perhaps be possible to just replace R2 from some other shot?

What? His panels are horrendous in the SE. They are just blocks of colour that aren't even rotoscoped properly and are all over the place.

Harmy said:

Oh, I just watched Ady's latest clip again and I see that he actually did add a bit of impact shake to that shot I posted before, just much less. Sorry, Ady :-)

Thats ok ;).I didn't add a dramatic one as it is hitting water and not land, so wouldn't be so harsh. I have also given the same treatment to the shot when Luke crashes his speeder

I have only just been able to skim though the comments and haven't been able to reply yet as i'm absolutely knackered from looking after dad, so i'll try to reply when i get a bit of free time.