logo Sign In

Post #500215

Author
Erikstormtrooper
Parent topic
Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/500215/action/topic#500215
Date created
18-May-2011, 12:14 AM

Harmy, here's the rest of my review:

40:30 - Gout seems to cut to Mos Eisley view just a frame later than Despecialized Edition. (no biggie, just something I noticed)

40:43 - Your re-created background of Mos Esiley seems to be a little less sharp than I remember seeing in your clips.

48:50 - I know you've already worked miracles with this scene. I just wish there was a way to reduce the jumpiness of the GOUT footage.

49:41 - The double wipe is still too noticeable. Can you do any more with GOUT footage, like blend it in as the fade gets darker?

1:21:10 (and 1:21:17) - Can the previous shot of the falcon in the hangar (which you restored beautifully) be zoomed in and used here?

1:25:40 - Obi Wan's saber seems to suffer from a small well-defined tip that extends beyond the fuzzy glow.

1:27:32 - Strange blue haze around the falcon's engines. Maybe that's supposed to be there, but it looks weird. It reminds me of the blue haze in the SE's death star explosion.

1:29:02 - Garbage matte around TIE is particularly noticeable. I hope you can tone this down.

1:55:29 - Sound drops off before credits finish. You probably know this though ;)

These are the only faults I can find. Otherwise, this is spectacular, and will probably be the only version (other than Revisited) that I allow to be shown in my house. Thanks!