I want you(r snobby opinions on art)

I need opinions on which piece you think would serve best for the "cover art" of my audio drama (Plug).

Note: These are all rough sketches

1: (drawn last night)

2: (Also drawn last night)

3: (Drawn approx. a month ago)

Edit: I forgot to say that I think that I am by no means a great artist.

Yeah, I really just want to know which concept is best or maybe suggestions that you think would make a good cover.

Anyway, my conceptual process is to draw it on paper, import it into photoshop/corel painter, make a new layer to trace the lines with my pen tablet then fill in the colars in the background. Not sure how well this will work as I've never tried it.

I like the third one too. Shows nice depth, not just a boring side-by-side lineup. The first one is a good concept but doesn't do justice to the intimidating size of the destroyer. Don't like the second one so much.

HotRod said:

BloodnoseThePirate said:

Edit: I forgot to say that I think that I am by no means a great artist.

 

No shit!!!

 

;)

Geeza!  Where you been, man?

Leonardo said:

 that's a Star Destroyer isn't it?

Lol, yeah.

What if I did something like number 3 with the star destroyer looming above them. My only concern with that is that it will take away the feeling of menace from the empire.

Yeah, I personally like the second one also. I think I'm going to do a combination of all of them. With a bigger Star Destroyer.

First one due to sheer awesomeness.