zombie84 said:

. Someone says "I wonder if Criterion could do SW." Someone else says, "Criterion isn't very good so why would you want that?" Three other people then say "actually, they are very good as seen in these examples."

Well... to be fair, someone said:

SO : Criterion always does a great job.
I     : Not always. 2 of the 4 I have suck.
SOE: They don't suck, they have great special features (including alternate cuts)!
I     : Yeah, I mean the A/V sucks.
SOE2: It was as good as could be had at the time.
I     : Er... no it wasn't.

And it went on from there.