Seems response at starwars.com isn't too positive:
GuardianKen said:
I do like the complete saga box art, but the individual trilogy box art looks terrible, like someone dropped the ball
boffomusicguy said:
All my favorite moments? Really? I'll list them.-Han shoots first.-Jabba is not in Episode IV-We never see the full Wampa creature on Hoth.-In Episode V, the Emperor has the face of an old woman and is actually voiced by Clive Revill as the end credits state.-We don't see Vader return to his Super Star Destroyer after dueling Luke in Episode V-Hayden Christensen is not Anakin's force ghost in Episode VI-The original music from the end celebration in Episode VI.Now, if the set delivers those moments in full HD and 6.1 DTS Master Audio, I'll pre-order tomorrow (which is payday for me), otherwise, as previously stated, I will not buy it or accept it as a gift.
JoeC said:
This countdown to star wars day was a major disappointment. Has a lifelong fan of the original trilogy I felt betrayed.
jeditito36 said:
Not at all excited about the box art
Jedi Sprite said:
I'm sorry Lucasfilm but the Complete Saga artwork is terrible.
Too bad most of the critical comments seem to be about the artwork and not the actual movies (or lack thereof).