The Aluminum Falcon said:

Have you seen some other ROTS edits, Erikstormtrooper? If so, how does the Killer Sandbox compare?

I have seen a couple, but I can't remember the names right now. I really haven't seen that many. My personal test of an Episode III edit is the Dooku flip. If an editor has left this in, I know the edit's not for me.

The Killer Sandbox version tries to emulate the Phantom Editor's approach, just cutting out what doesn't work. He even uses the same movie header with countdown at the beginning, like the Phantom Editor did.