I have absolutely no problem admitting that I like Ady's additions where-as I hate Lucas/ILM's additions.

The clincher for me is that Ady has talent, where-as Lucas/ILM made (and continue to make) ham-fisted attempts at improving portions of the film, wether it needs it or not.

In MY opinion, Ady makes alterations and/or additions where they are quite logical, and in some places very necessary. I think he shies away from making changes just because he can, and sticks to fixing things he sees as problematic. Additionally, if he discoveres that he can't make something look just right, he'll abandon making the change as he would rather leave something unaltered than mess it up even more....which (again, in MY opinion) shows alot more integrity than Lucas/ILM has shown in their treatment of the films.

EDIT: Quite right, Ady is not a God.....I did not agree with all of his changes, but I DO think that his blend into the original film far better than anything Lucas/ILM have come up with