Alexrd said:
timdiggerm said:
ANH? Luke's father and Darth Vader weren't even the same person.
That's hard to say, since Alec's acting makes it possible either way.
Yeah, 'possible either way' in a retro-active sense. Occam's razor can help: Alec's demeanor in the scene - his acting, as you mention it - is because Obi-Wan is having to tell his friend's son that his father was murdered , when it's obvious that Luke just knew - or was told by his uncle - up to that point only that his father had died.