But you haven't bolded Pirates of Penzance and Into the Woods!?!?

Have you not seen them, or you've seen and unliked them?

I grew up on the Penzance movie, so I can't be trusted to give an honest review... but it's on of our favourites. It just came out on DVD in the past six months- my young kids have watched it, and they thought it was pretty good.

I'd say definitely check it out if you haven't already.

And, as Warb pointed out, Fiddler is definitely a great musical. I was thinking about it as I made my list, but somehow managed to not actually put it on the list.