Warbler said:

xhonzi said:

Johnny Ringo said:

Musicals can be good if they are cheesy fun and don't take themselves too seriously - like Repo or Across the universe or indeed Dr Horrible.

Wait, are Repo and Across the Universe your examples of good musicals?

There are some much beloved musicals I don't like at all: South Pacific, Carosel, Oklahoma (to some degree), and others. Something being a 'musical' doesn't really increase or decrease my chance of liking something I guess... but I do like a fair number of musicals.

<snip>

That's all I can think of presently.

hey!!!! what about 1776?

Wow, you're totally right! How did that one skip my mind. I'll put it near the top.

I also forgot Guys'n'Dolls, though it's really only based on a high school performance I saw when I was in Jr High.