haha no, it just came up in other threads, I promise!
I tried doing a not so bold trim edit of this, but it didn't satisfy me in the end. I say it in my commentary a little, bit this is a nut I've been trying to crack pretty much since I started fanediting. I don't know too many editors who have tried drastically different things on the same movie three times, so you can see how desperate I was to get it right. The fact that I'm satisfied with this edit is particularly exciting to me, and I've got the quality on it at the highest level I'm capable of.
This is as close as I can get to the version of Jedi that i always wanted the original to be. Tastes are different, and again I said in my commentary that Star Wars is interesting because it means different things to different people, so one persons "perfect version" can never apply to everyone. Still, I hope you all enjoy it, whether it's as a definitive version or a fun alternate.