logo Sign In

Post #476281

Author
OzoneSherrif
Parent topic
Tarkin in the clone wars.
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/476281/action/topic#476281
Date created
21-Feb-2011, 12:33 AM

adywan said:

One thing that gets me is that they have managed to make chewies face look like he does in the OT yet lucasfilm made him look completely different for ROTS.I never understood how they could get the face so wrong in ROTS.

The carbon freezing plot is bloody ridiculous though and completely ruins the danger of Han getting frozen in ESB. Lando says that if they put Luke in there it might kill him, so Vader tests it out on Han. Why would he have bothered if he knew it was a safe procedure? And they have Ugnaughts controlling the carbon chamber in TCW so you could take it that they are some sort of experts at carbon freezing, so no danger then. I have a bad feeling that Lucas will add more dialogue in the blu-ray version of ESB:

Lando: "You put him in there it might kill him.

Vader: "no, i've done it myself, it's perfectly safe"

As much as i like TCW, there are moments that just scream fanwank

yep it was completely ridiculous. add to that the multiple carbon freezing chambers off to the side of the Jedi/clone hangar bay. why would that even be there