ChainsawAsh said:

fishmanlee said:

ChainsawAsh said:

fishmanlee said:

ChainsawAsh said:

The music heard over "Bring my shuttle" is far better than the music heard over "Alert my Star Destroyer," too.

You mean the music is better utilized over "Bring my shuttle"

No, I'm fairly certain it's a different cue, necessitated by the addition of all those pointless "flying to the Executor" shots. They're definitely both based around the Imperial March, but they're not the same cue.

That is what I meant

But you made is seem that the new music was not as good as the other, and I said no, it did not fit the scene, but it was good (its John Williams).

Yeah, that's exactly what I meant. The SE cue is inferior. The original cue is better musically than the cue used in the SE.

Just because it's John Williams doesn't mean it's inherently as good as other John Williams.

Well it was composed for the movie, but not for the scene, so it was good for the movie, but not good for the scene they used in, it was tracked from when Vader tells Luke he is his father (but you already knew that)