I think I'm with Ady on just having the names of those who actually put some work into the edits... you know, kinda like what the movie credits do anyways (list those who actually worked on the movie).

It will be nice to see my name in the list on EMPIRE:R.... maybe (though I have a feeling it will be like the "Bart gets a bit part on the Krusty the Clown show" episode, when he points out his name in the end credits as they fly by), but here is another idea (regardless of acceptance).

Only list the names of those whose ideas you actually use. That way, if someone posts just to get their name on a list, they won't unless they actually offer a reasonable suggestion, much less one worthy of using (since if it is used, that would mean some sort of involvement for giving a usuable idea).

I guess you could say it is the difference between the STORY BY and SCRIPT BY credits... one is for the idea and creation of the story, whereas the other is the actual written development and final execution of that idea. The script could be almost completely different from the initial idea (Dan O'Bannon's ALIEN versus Walter Hill's ALIEN), but the creator of the idea still gets credit.