Bingowings said:
To rip into the PT and not ROTJ seems like a double standard to me but I am not he.
Well, he never said those movies were without flaws or plot holes when bitching about the new ones, did he? He often brought up the original trilogy as a positive example for some general, narrative aspect, including ROTJ, and it was always right on the money, so I don't complain.
I agree that mentioning the plot weaknesses of the old trilogy, and not just ROTJ, and putting them into perspective along with the PT's, would've made for a "fairer" and more interesting series of reviews, but hey - watch his ST09 review and you already know what his OT reviews would look like.
;)