Topper Harley said:

While a version like this is really nice quality-wise, it's edit is dependent on personal choices and with every cgi-shot I think I am watching the special edition again.

The question is, what is your main goal you want to achieve: Is it important for you, that you never see a quality-jump? Then probably you will be better served with a theatrical reconstruction in DVD-resolution or the partly despecialized edition. For me on the other side it would be the main goal to watch a movie that is completely despecialized with as much HD footage as possible.

I wouldn't mind so much, when the GOUT shots, are revealed as being lower quality. Sure, they would need to be color corrected, to fit in. I am also not so sure about all the cleaning for the GOUT that has been going on, because if done too excessive, the picture can appear very lifeless and too clean.

Exactly, I'd like to see something like this as well. I wouldn't mind at all if there would be GOUT or even straight LD quality between shots but if there's even one CGI shot then I'm not interested. That's why I haven't watched Ady's or Harmy's work yet, hopefully some day there's a possibility to realize this idea. If people can watch the GOUT as is then I don't see a problem using it along with HD quality.