BarBar Jinkx said:

rpvee said:

Nicely done, but it'd be more confusing than anything, imo.

How so, I found it much more coherent and logical than what we were given in the official release

Because it establishes that Cody has talked to Sidious before, which confuses the viewer as there have been no hints at such a character development before. If Sidious just talks and Cody replies, it implies more that he's directly taking an order without thought as opposed to having a conversation. Kinda hard to explain.