Yeah, they finally finished the "Workprint" cut of 3 for the Blu-Ray. You don't feel like you're watching half a movie anymore - it could have been released in theaters that way in 1992.
Anyway, my vote is and always shall be for Alien.
Alien - 5
Aliens - 5
(as Frink was the last one to post a vote, I'm using his 4-5 count. I agree that MJPollard's votes don't count.)