TV's Frink said:

MJPollard said:

Alien - 5

Aliens - 5

Sorry, but I like both equally, but for different reasons. Alien is a great horror movie, while Aliens is a great action movie. Comparing them, let alone pitting them against each other, makes this one of the stupidest threads I've ever seen, and that's saying a lot for this forum.

This is one of the stupidest posts ever. And that's saying a lot for this forum.

I'd like to clarify my statement. Both movies, different though they may be, are Alien movies. There's no good reason we can't compare and contrast them, and it certainly is generating discussion.

There's nothing wrong with not wanting to choose one over the other. But calling this thread stupid is...well...stupid.

Anyway, I'm assuming the OP will invalidate your votes, given the insulting nature of your post, so I'm taking the liberty of resetting the vote back to 4-4. And thus...

Alien - 4

Aliens - 5