This isn't about scary movies that are good. I'm not interested in straight up quality. I want to know what movies scared YOU personally. What flick made you want to sleep with a night light?
BLACK CHRISTMAS (the original) is one for me. I watched it for the first time, last year, on Netflix streaming, sitting in my office. That's about the least immersive way to watch a movie. And yet it scared the crap out of me. I was freaked out all night.