logo Sign In

Post #465816

Author
Gaffer Tape
Parent topic
Gaffer Tape's YouTube Reviews of Awesome Candy-Creating Goodness! (The Facts of Life/Star Trek III Conspiracy!)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/465816/action/topic#465816
Date created
20-Jan-2011, 3:16 PM

Yeah, apparently Ronald Moore used the excuse that field commissions stick or that it's an old tradition to defer to the commanding officer of a ship, despite real rank (earlier in the season, when Jadzia took command of the Defiant, everyone called her captain), but I still feel it's a lot of bunk.  I mean, what if it had been Worf who'd been picked up by the Valiant?  I have a hard time believing he'd put up with Ferris's bullshit and having to call her "sir."

It's interesting, though.  This review has really brought out a lot of people who are just "meh" about the series in general but totally in love with Voyager, which surprised me.  I admit I don't hang out in Trek circles much.  I guess I'm just used to sfdebris and confused matthew, who both praise DS9 and condemn Voyager to the lowest levels of hell.  To be honest, as I said in the video, I love DS9 precisely because it broke free from Roddenberry's conflict-free, homogenous utopia and shows that, no matter how evolved we get, we're always going to have some kind of dark side to us.  In that respect, it feels a lot like Star Trek VI to me, which is one of my favorite Trek films.

Thanks, as always, for the feedback.  And, really, I need a haircut? ;_;