dark_jedi said:
Well I don't know what to tell you Mielr, I don't see all this red you are talking about and I really don't like DrM's tweaks as of yet, it barely changes anything, and definitely not worth a new render and encode, like I have said, if more tweaking needs to be done make your suggestions to what you want done, because if WE don't come up with something soon it stays as is, there is NO way in hell I am doing a scene by scene, I really don't think it is worth it to me, I honestly can't see how you don't think this latest tweak is not better than "as is", but everyone see's these colors different I guess.
Sorry, I don't mean to confuse the issue - the only reason I chimed in was because you asked for my input (I had not said anything up until that point) and I happened to have a cel of one of the scenes in question from the last batch, and thought that it might help. Of course, I don't expect that you would do scene-by-scene color correction as it definitely would not be worth the extra work.
I haven't looked at DrMs other tweaks. I was only referring to DrM's tweaking of the film cel I provided for comparison, and in comparison to the examples you provided the skin and jumpsuit look redder in your versions, as they look on my MacBook screen. Of course you may not see the red I'm seeing because of the difference in our monitors, and therein lies the problem.
The colors on the V1 and V2 look fine to me, so use your own judgement. :-)