logo Sign In

Post #458633

Author
haljordan28
Parent topic
anothe example of lucas changing things to appeal to a new generation lightsaber dueling styles of OT vs PT
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/458633/action/topic#458633
Date created
20-Dec-2010, 7:42 PM

dont get me wrong. there are actually some things I like aboyut the PT.  I like qui gon.  I like darth maul.  I feel they both should have lived   up till episode 3.    I did like the duel  from episode 1.  out of all 3  pt films I think  episode  1  was the most like the  ot.   when qui gon first encounters  maul on tattoine.  i think that saber duel looks like the OT duels .  while i hated the idea of a kid anakin  i felt there was still hope after episode 1  but after  episode 2 i knew the whole thing was lost.  episode 2 is the worst film ever made in my opinion.  for so many reasons.

 

not only  the screenplay  but the logic of it all.   padme  was trying to be  assinatied  and  mins later  she is standing out on an open balconey  in the middle of the city.  the  whole anakin jumping out of the speeder and falling 200 feet  and landing on the other speeder.  not to mentioned the way anakin just cries and whines and is disrespectful  to his master from the very first scene.  there is no way to get  attached to this character.  he is completely unlikeable.  it did nothing to touch on anything the whle back story was suppose to be about and then they cram 3 movies into one for episode 3.  its all one big mess.