I like the lightsaber fight in TPM. As I said, I actually like the film, just not as much as any of the OT.

ROTS has its moments. They're very few and far between, though, and don't make up for the poor, disjointed plotting.

I stand by my theory that everything that happens in ROTS should have happened over the course of all three prequels - cramming them all into ROTS makes for a very disjointed, hyperactive film that just doesn't feel like a cohesive whole at all.

Hell, even AOTC has its moments. And by that, I mean Obi-Wan's detective work, and that's about it. The rest of that movie blows pretty hard.