vaderios said:
It might be good, but it looks like crap ;)
Just to clarify, my 2¢ on the floating X-wing shot: I like the added detail of the trees in the background of your mock-up, but I dislike the brightness of the image. As someone else recently stated, the gloomy feel of Dagobah should not be sacrificed.
As for the shot of the X-wing's wing in the water, I like the elimination of the vignette around the edges, but the altered colours don't work (see previous comment re: maintaining gloominess).
... in my opinion :)