Well... this seems to be disintegrating into a furball. ^^ And I'm not the cause for once... =D Although I think I'll add to it for the fun of it knowing most likely I'll be banned... but what the heck, it'll save Ady some sanity I hope.
As such, I'm gonna throw this out there cos this is really what I think as I've heard lots about this in general. I overall have no interest in what anyone here thinks of me or care to interfere... and this is how I roll overall. It's a message board... ooo... I'm really shaking now concerning opinions...
I am, however, Ady's friend... and so as such...
Vaderios, stop asking for/suggesting Lucas-level unnecessary additions that add nothing to story or the integrity of these classic movies. The bulk of your suggestions/renders feed your own need for the spotlight here otherwise you would of taken your over colored, overly brighten, overly sharpened, overly rendered mock ups and made YOUR OWN group to post on.
In fact, I highly suggest it as you seem to have a small following of your own and all, then maybe you can make YOUR OWN edit. If you're SO good then it should be easy for such a talent as yourself to create your own revisited rather than latch on to the coat tails of Adywan here. That's sounds good to me... Vaderio's Revisited. Good luck with that...
More over, if you continue your actions here as mere "suggestions" and are butting heads with Ady... More or less, then maybe, JUST MAYBE, this is a hint eh? Sure your pictures are shiny/colorfully pretty just like any one picture can be looking nice with enough time and dedication... but I've yet to see them move from you. I think that's kinda key to any film really... The whole making them move thing... So for all you guys "ohhhhing" and "ahhhhing" over an amazing Vaderios mock up... perhaps all of you should also consider the technical ramifications of making such ideas work in MOVEMENT and the over all cost of these things in general to make them MOVE.
Oh wait... only a few of us do... cos Ady pays for the bulk of this on his own (as well as generous donations from fans who want to see a better Star Wars for us all) to improve or enhance things without going Lucas-level uber (or Vaderios-level uber) but he does it so tactfully the bulk of us barely notice. Therefore you're like, oh it's so clear but it looks like Ady didn't do much. Think again people... There is always a cost to make these MOVING effects even if it's just "clearer" and such while making it look amazing and more over... FREE for the bulk of us.
I've also noticed on several occasions that Ady would ask how you did something or how something in your mock up was achieved. I'd personally consider it the height of collaboration with Adywan if he asked me to "open the help files" to improve something we all love. However, you tend to give vague cheeky answers and more or less hint at a trade of information and the like. Perhaps a exclusive clip... Perhaps an exclusive picture... doesn't matter, as long as it's something no one else has seen. My guess, it's an ego thing, it caters to your need to feel special to have something no one else has or can see. As is the bulk of your mock ups... ohhh.... ahhhh...
Regardless, since Ady is hesitant to release such information to you (because if you're bold enough to offer a "trade" concerning information/clip, who knows what you'd trade this for with others eh?Duh...). Your only recourse now cos you're NOT getting anything is to undermine Ady's work when ever you can without opening saying what you want is credit that is not rightfully yours. This is blatantly apparent.
Now, obviously I don't post here usually cos really... I've seen and dealt with too many things like this in other groups. However, for Ady's continuation of this project without you for the next 5 films would be a blessing and I think a lil exercising of cancer is in order before it metastasis further...
Take a good look at the title of this group.
"STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"**ADYWAN**
No where does it say Vaderios... if you're as good as your think you are then start your own revisited and leave Ady in peace. Your suggestions are impractical to with what Ady has in mind and more over unaccepted. Get the hint...
Bye all! Happy holidays! ^^