shanerjedi said:

Vaderios I remember that Dagobah mockup you did with Luke and Yoda in the background as the X-Wing floats up. Still love t.

Thanks.

Still a mockup for the bad vignette effects...

Matching the continuity and the lightning of the previous shots this shadow area should not be present. Not only apears on the sky but it embraces the fog of the lake too.

Ady fixed some of them in hoth battle, hopefully he might try these too

Edit:

Ady i noticed that your lens blur/fas blur from the unfocused shots even from ANH:R was not match with the lens blur of the 70/80s cameras. ESB shows us that when an object is unfocused it has a certain behaviour. For example if you see unfocused lights you can notice an edge around the unfocused element. Taking advandange of this and assuming you are having many shots with BG replacement why not try to make as close as possible to the 80s cameras using a more calibrated blur. More control it might have this plugin http://www.borisfx.com/units/LensBlur.php

I remember but im not sure that Andrew Kramer showed a technique that you can make a short of pseudo but realistic looking sharp edged lens blur with a couple of steps.

-Angel