Lemonstein said:
Wow, shoot me for saying it, but can't people wait till Ady releases the finished movie before they start dissecting it. It's a bit unfair to start picking at it when you're not viewing it as a whole.
People have always dissected these clips when adywan posts them. It's part of the way things work on this thread. I think, like a professional, ady welcomes reactions of all kinds, or he wouldn't post the clips or engage in debate afterward. I've never seen him begrudge criticism, as long as it's not beating a dead horse, because such nitpicking and obsessive-compulsive geekery is what inspired such an awesome concept as fan-edits in the first place.
Besides, people want to dissect because there's a chance maybe that something noticed will have a positive impact on the finished product. In my experience, Ady seems to pretty thoughtfully consider all criticism, positive and negative. So, I wouldn't worry about a few people picking apart a clip. It's all in the interests of making the best Star Wars fanedit possible.