logo Sign In

Post #452519

Author
adywan
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/452519/action/topic#452519
Date created
9-Nov-2010, 10:37 PM

Monroville said:

My only real beef with the last shot is the trajectory of the Falcon - regardless of the galaxy being a "galaxy" or newly-forming star (or whether it is replaced by something completely different, slightly different or altogether pretty much the same thing), just seeing the Falcon veer off to the middle to upper left just looks wrong.  You almost want to yell out "Hey Lando!  The friggin galaxy is THAT way!"

you see that's why i don't think it was ever meant to be the galaxy and the explanation that came a long time after the film was released that said it was the galaxy is just another of the many history revisions surrounding these movies.  Now ILM do these shots, which are all carefully planned, and add a view of the galaxy. So why the hell did the falcon fly AWAY from it? If it was supposed to be the fleet outside of the galaxy wouldn't they have had the falcon fly towards it? I'll always see it as a forming star.

I will be adding more ships to the fleet to eliminate the static matte of the ships in the final shot, as well as other shots. Plus the falcon as it undocks from the medical frigate has a new falcon model to eliminate the really bad transparency issue and when we see it fly from the frigate from the window point of view the falcon has been replaced so it flies from the correct section of the ship instead of the incorrect way it emerges from underneath the window. In fact every shot of the falcon from its undocking, the model has been replaced