zombie84 said: Well, what I said is that he is mistaken in insisting that the previous transfers are how the film should look and the yardstick by which to measure the film.

He didn't. He said that he had seen the films theatrically and thought that the previous transfers were closer in terms of color. You didn't qualify the "you are mistaken" remark at all, and I certainly didn't take it the way you say you meant it.

zombie84 said: This is still a fault. It doesn't matter if the DC is not 100%, it's still a mistake to take it to task for deviating from the previous transfers since the previous transfers were not accurate either, nor are theatrical prints (and ones memory of theatrical prints).

I don't recall anyone taking the DC to task for deviating from previous transfers of the theatrical cut. Some people don't like the fact that the theatrical version is timed in the same way as the DC. I am not one of them, and I generally agree wtih you about the Blu-ray transfers, but I can certainly understand that point of view.