logo Sign In

Post #450427

Author
msycamore
Parent topic
Complete Comparison of Special Edition Visual Changes
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/450427/action/topic#450427
Date created
27-Oct-2010, 11:30 AM

LexX said:

How about SW and ROTJ?

SW is already checked, there's no difference in holograms between the JSC and GOUT but they removed the horizontal scanlines for the SE, how Jedi is, I don't know.

zombie84 said:

Aha. So the scanlines are definitely entirely different elements between the GOUT and JSC. Its not a DVNR thing, these are two separate versions of the composites.

Yes, it seems like it. The only explanation must be minor 70mm/35mm - cut differences if they didn't change things later for a video release, both options seems weird, why would 70mm material suddenly appear in a 35mm-final cut and why would they bother to alter these minor things for a video release in '93 or '86 and perhaps even earlier and which of the composites is the earliest one...?