TV's Frink said

The rules are meant to be simple, cut and dried. But this issue is more complex than that. Either moderator discretion must be allowed, or there will be lots of banning.

Dude has a point. For example, if i was to make a post say about how AT-ATs fall over in a serious thread and i just replied with:

even though its on topic and just supposed to be comedy relief, would i get a warning for not being constuctive to a thread?

There are gray areas.

And do the mods have the time to take on the increased policing of the site?

I agree it needs doing absolutly, but not with an iron rod to stick with Jays statement.