rockin said:
bobgarcia74 said:
Need some fresh eyes for this next shot, cause I've been looking at it for so long. ATM anything looks good.
During the final duel I removed the line. "You underestimate my power". For obvious reasons. My problem was that with alot of the lines from this part removed, Anakin jumping comes way to quick. So I reinserted the shot when Anakin gives that line, but removed him saying anything. Using motion tracking and masks. Feel free to pick it apart, cause like I said, right now it's hard for me to judge it.
That actually works quite nicely bob. With that line gone, it makes the scene more tense. :-)
It isn't only more tense, but more dramatical, more tragical, more real, and that MUST be the spirit of the scen, congratulations bob!. Obi chopping Anakin off isn`t bad at all. Leaving would be a really really powerful situation but it wouldn't go well with the part of Yoda warning Obi Wan about letting Anakin alive. What about force chokin' him to the lava? Then there'd be no "You were the chosen one. You were my brother..." Just Obi Wan leaving, disappointed.
Regarding the dialogue previous to the duel between padme and Anakin, I was planning to see what could be done to it, would it bother you if I posted here my "conclussions"?. Perhaps you have already made a decission about it.
Wow... The best thing about fan edits is that things get really enhaced. The bad one is that you realize how many things could be done to improve the movie, and how limited material you have to do it, and eventually you end up regreting that Lucas has missed such a big chance, isn't it?