hairy_hen said:

True, I don't think there's anything significant to be gained from using older versions of the Rancor scene. The compositing, the contrast, and the general picture quality of the '04 in this case are all far better, and switching to older shots just isn't worth it. It's still all the original source material, basically just cleaned up; it's not like there was any CGI that needed replacing.

I agree 100%. As it's still the same scene only superior in quality i think its a better idea to include the 04 footage . Just a sugestion Harmy as its your work , your call .