Quote
Originally posted by: HotRod
Quote
Originally posted by: SpecialEditionSaboteur
Quote
Originally posted by: HotRod
vtpeters

I doubt if GL meant for Obi-wan to "speak in tongues" if you will, I think he only made it look that way as each movie came along in order to make it easier for him to cover up his previous mistakes. That's why that conversation with Luke was added in ROTJ; so people could make sense out of Obi-wan telling Luke that Vader killed his father in ANH.

So yes, they are plot holes--or were.

No they are not man...

Look...Put it this way...

Luke has just met Obi Wan...

Do you really think Obi wan is gonna blurt out what happened to Lukes father straight away...no he is not..

"Hello Luke...Oh by the way, your father was my best friend, but couldnt handle the way I was treating him, so he joined up with the Emporor and killed your mother and eevryone who cared for him..Then F****d off and ruled the Galaxy with his new master....Don't want to scare you or anything but it might happen to you too...Oh and heres his lightsabre"

No..........

See....George knows what he is doing!!!

Yeah. I think Lucas planned to have Vader be Luke's father all along, otherwise they would'nt have put so much emphasis on him in A New Hope. Lines like "the Force is strong with this one" make more sense in the context of Vader being Lukes father, since Vader is the second strongest in the Force ever. Also, Luke has met Ben Kenobi before A New Hope. Watch the scene again. Luke doesn't introduce himself.