OK. I'll bite. Here's what I liked.
Episode I:
- Destroyer Droids
- Seeing all the droids scramble to repair Amidala's ship. It was a great way to show what astromech droids are actually designed to do.
- The look of Coruscant
- Liam Neeson's performance in general
- The lightsaber battle at the end of the movie
- Wondering how these story threads would play out over the next two movies
Episode II:
- The opening sequence as Padme's new ship flies through the foggy skies of Coruscant
- The look of the new digital Yoda
- The scenes of Clones marching in formation
- Ewan McGregor's & Christopher Lee's performances
- The scene between Obi Wan and Dooku, where Dooku reveals the senate is controlled by a Sith Lord
- Fantasizing that Episode III would be about the Clone Wars
Episode III:
- The epic scale of the opening space battle
- The ROTS clone armor as a nice transition between Episode II and Episode IV
- The EMOTIONAL IMPACT of Anakin's turn to the Dark Side (this part of the movie has a lot of emotion, even if the plot and logic behind the turn are lacking)
- The tension I felt before and during the final saber battle on Mustafar: How would Obi-Wan defeat Anakin?