Quote
Originally posted by: HotRod
vtpeters
Those aren't plot holes man....
Yoda - Obi wan training thing...Well you've explained that yourself, so no holes in the plot there...
Obi-Wan "took it upon himself to train him as a Jedi" - Which he did....I don't think that was the right time for Obi-Wan to tell Luke his life story....not with the big battles, and Death Stars going on an shit!!
Again....
I'm sure George Lucas knows his films...He did right them in the first place.....
Ok, so he's changing them....So...
He's not changing them so much that it's full of holes...
No, now he's just adding to an already great story!
Of course they're not plot holes now, George Lucas corrected his mistakes as each movie was produced. Which was the point vtpeters was trying to make.
I doubt if GL meant for Obi-wan to "speak in tongues" if you will, I think he only made it look that way as each movie came along in order to make it easier for him to cover up his previous mistakes. That's why that conversation with Luke was added in ROTJ; so people could make sense out of Obi-wan telling Luke that Vader killed his father in ANH.
So yes, they are plot holes--or were.