CO wrote:
if you listen to their arguments, they are all bullshit, or excuses why they think the PT is good.
Take each comment and refute it. The problem is you're dealing with opinions and feelings...
But with quotes like these below, where do you want the debate to go?
CO wrote:
I have never tried to convince someone that the PT is bad,
*edit*
excuses why they think the PT is good.
So one of them is working on a documentary about the fandom split. I recommended that he consider looking into the other splits fandom has gone through. As CO has explained:
CO wrote:
If you ask a majority of OT fans, MOST of us readily admit Jedi is the worst of the 3 and understand its shortcomings
*and*
Atleast the fans of the OT will readily admit that Jedi is not as great as SW & Empire
This is an example of one of the fissions in OT fandom. There's also the camp who only believe in the original SW. Spelling out the creative decisions which lead to splits or how the audience changed sounds more interesting then continually reading this stuff and face palming yourself.
20th Century Mark wrote:
Just the fact that this has its own pannel
Hard to say if LFL is just latching onto this part of fandom or do they really believe there is need for this.