logo Sign In

Post #43892

Author
ricarleite
Parent topic
Plot holes in the SW saga
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/43892/action/topic#43892
Date created
18-Apr-2004, 5:32 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: HotRod
Actually in Jimbos defense...

In 1980 when Empire cam out, you could by a folding poster thing. On the back was a load of info an shit!!
One had a piece about the Empire, and it stated there that the Stormtroopers were clones...

Also, Jimbo is correct in saying, if Goerge Lucas says they are Clones, then they are Clones.
They may not have been once, but they are now!




They are now, I totally agree. I was just saying that he changed his mind.

And if this folding poster thing is official, and states clearly that they are all clones, and it came from GL or Lucasfilm itself, then I'll have to agree with you and Jimbo, and give GL a little bit more credit. But still, it conflits with the EU material, which clearly stated the opposite, and the official EU material is always aproved by GL, so... unless he didn't bother to read it:

"Mr. Lucas we have some new expanded universe material for you to approve."
"What? They still write those things? Ok, ok, tell me what are those about."
"The first one is a work of fiction called Tommy Skywalker, in which the band The Who meets Luke and decides to do an album about him."
"Approved. Next."
"We have 'Star Wars: ER', the story of a emergency hospital in Tatooine, during the events of A New Hope."
"Approved."
"And we have here... 'Star Wars Forbidden Love', in which Luke and Leia decide to ignore the fact they are twins, and decide to make noisy love inside an A-Wing, during the clone wars, which I belive is not even possible. It was written by a 13 year old boy, and it's 3 pages long."
"Whatever, approved, approved!"