STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW — Page 789

@ Mithrandir...That's where Lucas lost his marbles and screwed up the PT, he lost the story in all the "muck" of special effects and extra's that had no benefit towards making the movies better.

Remember it's about the story and not about all the "muck" just thrown in there just cause you can.

From what I've seen from Adys work so far on ESB:R (which isnt a whole lot,lol) I believe IMO he has things on the right track and knowing Ady he will have more than a few surprises for us that he'll keep secret until it's release.

Keep watching and posting...

@ DoubleoFive....you took the words out of my mouth.

Mithrandir and speaker-60 have to be trolling. Seriously, those aren't legitimate posts are they??!

Here's my favorite bit...

Mithrandir said:

I know that Adywan's point of view is that PT should be the one who gets near the OT, but still, imma gonna tell you what I want in ESB:R anyway.*

However, speaker-60 appears to want to do it him(her?)self and is just asking in the wrong place.

Those are some bold words, gurgle... ;)

TV's Frink said:

Here's my favorite bit...

Mithrandir said:

I know that Adywan's point of view is that PT should be the one who gets near the OT, but still, imma gonna tell you what I want in ESB:R anyway.*

However, speaker-60 appears to want to do it him(her?)self and is just asking in the wrong place.

Woa woa woa, I'm just trying to give my opinion here, I'm not tellin anybody what to do. May I misunderstood what's this thread about.

Besides, if you take a careful look at ANH:R, when Vader kills Ben, there's an issue (the incandescent scare) which we haven't seen during the whole OT. Adywan took it from the prequels, liked it and put it there.

I'm not asking you to agree with me, neither to support me, but the spirit of a forum is to share ideas. Nothing more, nothing less

Mithrandir said:

Besides, if you take a careful look at ANH:R, when Vader kills Ben, there's an issue (the incandescent scare) which we haven't seen during the whole OT. Adywan took it from the prequels, liked it and put it there.

What is an incandescent scare?

Sorry for the mistake. I'm not american. Actually english isn't my native language. I was referring to what you call "sabre burn marks", we haven't known those till PT

Mithrandir said:

Sorry for the mistake. I'm not american. Actually english isn't my native language. I was referring to what you call "sabre burn marks", we haven't known those till PT

Ah, I think you meant "scar" rather than "scare."

Mithrandir said:

Sorry for the mistake. I'm not american. Actually english isn't my native language. I was referring to what you call "sabre burn marks", we haven't known those till PT

Ady didn't add those because they were in the PT. He added scorch marks because that is how the physics of light sabers work.

I'm just saying that not all what's been introduced in the PT is useless or stupid, neither bad. Nor even for Adywan, whose "point of view is that PT should be the one who gets near the OT".

I didn't ever say that anything from the PT should be introduced just because it's on the PT. I just said that some stuff, if it fits properly and adds something to the story, could be considered. Just as it happened with the burn marks. For example; right after killing Ben, Vader goes away (when the blast door starts to close) and then when he realises taht the rebels are scaping, he turns round and comes to the hangar (fortunately the door is already closed). If I said, "hey there it'd have been cool to add the burn marks" I'd be giving my opinion, not saying "hey, add it!". It'd be just that, an opinion.

Loconut said:

Those are some bold words, gurgle... ;)

 yeah I dont know what happened there...fixed now I hope.

Mithrandir said:

I'm just saying that not all what's been introduced in the PT is useless or stupid, neither bad. Nor even for Adywan, whose "point of view is that PT should be the one who gets near the OT".

I didn't ever say that anything from the PT should be introduced just because it's on the PT. I just said that some stuff, if it fits properly and adds something to the story, could be considered. Just as it happened with the burn marks

Well, I don't understand adding the dome on the bottom of the SD. How would that change, made for the PT, add anything to the OT? If anything, that dome will be removed from the PT.

There is a rather beautiful accidental poetry about the combination of the words incandescent and scare.

Adywan had said that he will not be doing another version of ANH:R and I doubt he would introduce ideas that would clash with what he has already done in the finished and near finished projects he has done but there is always the ANH:SE Redux and ESB/ROTJ Wishlist threads for posting ideas for general use.

I have the upmost respect and envy for people who can post in languages other than their birth language.

I find it difficult enough to keep typos and grammatical errors out of posts in English.

The dome stuff, it was an idea that come out to me, and since I had the screenshot at hand, I posted it. Actually, the only thing it can do is give the SD's model a blue-lighted detail, so as to scape a little from gray, only a visual improvement... if you consider that an improvement...

But lets take another example:

EPIII, the Invisible Hand is falling (this happens two times). The firt time when the ship is under the command of general grievous. He orders to power the emergency booster engines. We see something weird in the engines, like a reverse engine.

Then when Anakin is piloting the ship, entering Coruscant's Atmosphere, he does something that "closes" the engines in order to stop the fall.

This "emergency mechanisms" are shown in the PT. Suppose you use them during the crash of Executor in ROTJ. They'd clarely add tension and drama to the scene. Maybe it'd be a radical change, radical enough to reject it, but it'd make a point to introduce it if it adds something, don't you think so?

Bingowings said:

 

I have the upmost respect and envy for people who can post in languages other than their birth language.

Glad to hear it. We try hard ! Please make an effort guys ;)

Mithrandir said:

The dome stuff, it was an idea that come out to me, and since I had the screenshot at hand, I posted it.

[...]

Maybe it'd be a radical change, radical enough to reject it, but it'd make a point to introduce it if it adds something, don't you think so?

 

Yes, but I think it's a good idea for all of us to think critically about what we want to suggest before we suggest it. If it's fixing a continuity error or goof, that's one thing. But if we're suggesting a change of some kind, it's worth being certain that it falls within Adywan's very clear concept before we post something that may spark two pages of off-topic posts. With nearly 20,000 posts in this thread, I think it's unfair to Adywan, who has to read through all of it, to say "I know this goes against your philosophy, but I'll share it anyway." Many, many times Ady has said he's not adding PT elements to ESB:R. No offense, but you haven't really suggested anything that "adds something" that ESB lacks.

To add to your post, if you have a suggestion that you KNOW Adywan will not accept, don't post it in this thread.  There is a separate thread for ESB and ROTJ suggestions to fan editors in general, that is not an Adywan-specific thread.  And there is yet another thread for ANH suggestions that is also not an Adywan-specific thread (this goes double for ANH, as Ady will not be doing any more revisions to ANH:R).