I've not read every single post in this thread so forgive me if I'm repeating what someone else has said.

Content-wise, I've got nothing to add or to criticize. Quite the opposite, it seems like the http://savestarwars.com page is a nice little summation of a lot of things people have been saying (and are right about) here for years. So my hat is off in terms of content.

However, in terms of presentation, it seems that the editorials are the site's main attraction. A good move might be to have some kind of brief intro text at the top of the homepage that very quickly summarizes what your page is all about and then, from there, lists of the various editorials. Off to the side, you can have that FAQ and the other sections as well.

Also, you may want to think about linking the text title of each editorial to the editorial's URL. For example, you would make the "How the Grinch Stole Star Wars" text into hyperlink text pointing to http://savestarwars.com/howthegrinchstolestarwars.html. And so on.