Easterhay said:
I am not anti-CGI by any means. But what does it say when the rubber puppet in ROTJ still looks more convincing than the CGI versions in ANH and TPM?
Yes. And even if ILM was somehow one day be able to get the CG to look exactly like the great ROTJ puppet, the scene still wouldn't belong in the movie no matter how much it's changed or tinkered with.