1Shouta said:
Reaction to certain scenes:
A New Hope:
"Your father wanted you to have this when you were old enough": Anakin didn't even know he had a son...
Jabba/Han scene: I imagined Han's boss to be a bit...different
Luke's falcon training: Isn't he supposed to have a blue lightsaber?
Obi-Wan vs Darth Vader: Wonder why Obi-Wan calls him, "Darth"...
Empire Strikes Back:
Luke & Leia kiss: Wait, didn't Padme name her babies Luke & Leia?
Yoda's appearance: Did...is Yoda on drugs or something? And his voice got...heavier
Cloud City entrance: I seriously doubt that this scene was in the original version...
Vader/Emperor scene: Palpatine looks exactly the same as he did in Episode III. Don't people age?
"I am your father": I already suspected this in either one of the movies since it's probably the most heard quote
Return Of The Jedi:
Jabba's appearance: *just realizes that Episode I had Jabba* Alright, Episode IV CG Jabba officially sucks. This is much better.
Leia says she remembers her mother: BULL. SHIT.
Palpatine's appearance: He looks like he lost weight compared to Episode III & V...
Unmasking scene: If Anakin was burned, why does he only have burn marks on the side of his cheek?
Anakin/Obi-Wan/Yoda final scene: Why is Anakin just looking around everywhere?
My dad's reaction to the final scene: Who's that guy on the left?
Now typing this out helps me see why the PT kinda ruined the OT.
Obi-Wan is lying to Luke about his father wanting him to have the lightsabre. Perfectly understandable in the context of what we know now. And isn't the way Alec Guinnes paused before replying to the question "How did my father die?" just perfect? It's as though Lucas had told him the backstory on the quiet.
Whatever you think you see in Ian's performance in ESB, he is actually wearing different makeup than what he wears in ROTS. Believe me, I originally thought it was the same but it really isn't.
And those burn marks on Anakin's head in the unmasking? The entire back of his head is burned; totally consistent with what we see in ROTS.
For me, far from ruining it, the PT actually enriches and deepens the OT.