Don't get me wrong, I think the movie release of the year 2011 is going to be The Empire Strikes Back. (And not the one on Blu-ray. ;) )

That doesn't mean the scene isn't dear to me. A single scene doesn't define a work. But what it does mean is that it's going to be a novelty item rather than a definitive improvement. All the more saddening since it appears to be the only one of it's kind in your edit. Can't say for sure.

And no, I didn't consider that I might be wrong. Because I can't be. There's nothing up to interpretation in the scene, it's fairly clear cut and fits well within the extremely loosely defined space physics of Star Wars. You just keep telling me I'm wrong even when I told you how I think I'm not and you are, instead of defending your position with counter examples. I'm looking for one of two outcomes here; either you come to see the error of your ways, or you show me how your version makes sense and adds to the movie. Neither is happening right now because you are being extremely defensive.

Oh, and Bingowings, there's a difference between disagreeing and pretty much telling me to get lost and stop disagreeing with anything adywan has done.

It doesn't only come up now, in fact this is the very reason I'm even on the forum to begin with. I sent adywan a PM about it as soon as I registered. The thread was full of other stuff and I didn't want to spam him about it. No reply, fast forward and Ady is having serious personal issues, not best time to talk about it, fast forward again and now I see thread has no large discussion going on and bring it up again.

And honestly, who came to www.originaltrilogy.com if not to bitch about small changes ruining a film forever?