Guys we have to realize that not everyone likes the same thing, even if the majority of a group likes it someone will always stand out as the oddball that does not.

Sure I find it strange too, thinking: "heeey, is this some kind of a windup by a troll"? or is he just the oddball person?

Strange though that he is willing to turn down the whole movie for one scene, it's not like this is some cheap arse Asylum movie made for a sci-fi channel release..so I would say to bad he does not have an open mind, his loss.

Wonder what this person thinks about what Lucas re-edited in this film!?

When it comes to fireing at the feeling rebel ship, I personally think it's a very good idea..how else could they be able to disable the transports? By pulling them over with tractor beams and giving them a ticket for speeding?

This is the reason why Captain Lennox says: "Good, our first catch of the day" because for them it's supposed to be an easy catch, if the ION cannon hadn't fried his ship I am sure he would have managed to stop the transport.

Strange thing is, why didn't Captain Lennox open fire in any of the Lucas (re-edited) film(s) if the plan was to catch the rebels..?