logo Sign In

Post #434263

Author
A B C
Parent topic
Dark_Jedi & ABC's - ESB: IMPERIAL EDITION - ART OF SCORING, Restored Recordings against the B&W GOUT - JW & LSO (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/434263/action/topic#434263
Date created
23-Aug-2010, 1:51 PM

 

'None',

Your 'Ben Burtt' exemple shouldn't occur for real jobs. I have a similar job than his in another area, and as far as I'm paid for a product that someone (who expects a professional definitive product) will purchase, I won't request an evaluation note. If my director is OK, then it's OK.

Most people who download our projects take the time to track out both our threads and the stuff we have uploaded. This torrent took 6 or 8 hours for me to download. And if you decided to watch the film in its entirety it takes two hours. I don't see where's the problem then in taking 2 or 5 minutes to give the least feedback, intelligent or not. They don't have to be from "specialists" every time, one of the big weakness on this site definitely. I'm actually glad of the lot of feedbacks of all kind I received for the "Audiophile Edition", and I could have quote here for exemples some that probably took only 2 min to tip but are enough to make you understand the sound is such as no one of the CD releases has reached.

It is time for people who track down such projects to have conscience that if we do this for pleasure, we' re not forced nor meant in any way to warn about these, nor share these away. They also have to understand most of the time they're able to find these thanks to other's feedbacks when they do, what is a major point. We could have just dealed this project for ourselves by pm with D_J, and it's possibly what may happen for any other plan.

Of course, this one is perhaps not the "project of the year" in the preservation forum for most people. The statement here stands for a wider consideration of the matter.

In the wait, I've just said it: "our pleasure!". Thanks for your words.