MagnoliaFan said:
Just because the scene was half assed in 83 doesn't mean it isn't real. That's probably why it was cut out of the film to begin with.

I claim the shots of Luke to be a fake because Mark Hamill has said on several occasions that they were never shot with him in it. Each time, he sounded much more sure of himself than I think that he did at CV ...

They could have shot another actor's hands holding the lightsaber back in '82. That just wasn't Hamill.

The composition of the shot follows the storyboard: http://www.starwarsholidayspecial.com/swcs/episode6/images/Luke-saber_storyboard_small.jpg

The other shots are obviously from the 80's. The corridor is well-known, and can be seen in Return of the Ewok here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y0dirZH0aKY (2:11)

ESHBG said:

Come on, guys, look at Luke's chin in that clip and look at Mark's chin...not even close!!!

LOL. I have seen other people post "That is definitely Mark Hamill's chin.".